Dear authors,
Both referees agreed that the manuscript needs major revisions to be considered for publication in SOIL. There are many deficiencies that must be addressed. Please, I encourage you to correct the manuscript thoroughly following the referees' comments.

I look forward to seeing the corrected version of the manuscript soon for reconsideration for publication.

Yours sincerely,

Dr. Raúl Zornoza
Universidad Politecnica de Cartagena
SOIL Topical Editor

Dear authors,
the manuscript has been greatly improved after the revision carried out. However, reviewers consider that the manuscript has to be further improved to be considered for publication. There are still some critical points related to Materials and Methods and mainly to the Discussion section. Please, thoroughly read the reviwers' comments and proceed to modify the manuscript accordingly. It is important you focus on the discussion and correctly address your findings with your own data trying to explain the behaviour observed. English should also be improved.

I am looking forward to read the revised version of the manuscript

Yours sincerely

Raúl Zornoza

Dear authors,
Although the manuscript has been improved by the revision developed, there are still some points you have to address to accept the manuscript for publication. Please, see all my comments on the attached pdf.
You have to focus on the statistical analysis results, and take in mind that if differences are not significant, it means that vinasse applications did not significantly affect soil loss and runoff. With this in mind, you have to rewrite your results and discussion as I propose directly on the pdf. I also suggest you to include the significant differences in your tables and figures so that the reader can easily interpret them.
You will see that I directly modified the content of the manuscript on the pdf, and also wrote comments.
I am looking forward to seeing the revised manuscript soon

Regards

Raul Zornoza

Dear authors,
There are some minor points you have to address before final decision. Please, see the attached pdf. I have directly modified some sentences, and included some comments.

Yours sincerely
Raúl Zornoza

Dear authors,
I will finally accept the manuscript for publication once you address some minor aspects I include in the attached pdf.

Yours sincerely
Raúl Zornoza

The manuscript can be published when the the following have been addressed:
1) Make suggested English improvements;
2) Remove the two references to EGU abstracts and replace with references to journal papers.

Specific instances where these improvements are needed are noted in the supplied annotated pdf file.

Also, be certain to address the technical corrections provided by the topical editor.

Thank you for submitting your work to SOIL!

Sincerely,
Eric C. Brevik