Dear,
I think there is an issue with the Green and Ampt model implementation in the Erosion 2/3D model. The use of the intial water pressure head as the water pressure head at the wetting front is not appropriate and a misinterpretation of the meaning of the pressure head at the wetting front. This misinterpretation is compensated by reducing the saturated hydraulic conductivity using a skin factor, which is in turn falsely interpreted as a reduction in saturated conductivity of a crust layer of dry soils.
In order to publish this work, these misinterpretations should be clarified. I attached a short study, which I in fact expected the authors to carry out as a response to the reviewer comments that clarifies my concerns.

Dear Dr. Beitlerová,

I think that the improvements you made to your paper are substantial so that I would propose its publication SOIL. Please find attached a commented pdf file with a few technical corrections. I especially appreciate the addition of Figure 7. I would just propose to add a bit more information about the parameters that were obtained or used to make the fits or predictions in the paper.

Dear authors,

Thank you for the thorough revision, your paper can now be published subject to technical corrections. Please carefully consider the final suggestions made by the topical editor before submitting your final version. Thank you for submitting your work to SOIL.

K Van Oost